DISPUTED CASES

69CASES

Cases where a specific conventional explanation has been proposed but is contested by witnesses, investigators or the evidence - or where only part of the case has been explained.

69 documented cases currently classed as disputed, spanning 1897 to 2025. 39 of them involved military witnesses or sensors. 43 have declassified government records, with 98 source documents linked in total.

Highest-credibility cases: USS Roosevelt Gimbal/GoFast Encounters (2015, scored 10/10), GoFast Video (2015, scored 9/10) and Chilean Navy Helicopter UFO (2014, scored 9/10).

How a case is classed: resolution criteria

2025•United States7/10

Palomar Observatory Nuclear-UAP Transients Study

Peer-reviewed Nature study found statistically significant correlations between 1950s sky anomalies, nuclear weapons testing, and UAP reports at Palomar Observatory.

DISPUTEDCE1
2024•United Kingdom8/10

RAF Lakenheath Drone/UAP Incursions

Unidentified objects forced a police helicopter into emergency evasive action over US air bases in England, with 20+ objects reported over three nights.

DISPUTEDCE1military
2024•United States6/10

New Jersey / East Coast Drone Mystery

Thousands witnessed unidentified drone-like objects over New Jersey and the Northeast near military installations, triggering national alarm before partial official explanations.

DISPUTEDmass-sighting
2024•China7/10

Tianjin Airport UAP Shutdown

Unidentified objects shut down Tianjin's international airport for three consecutive nights, grounding flights and prompting fighter jet scrambles across China.

DISPUTEDCE1military
2019•United States8/10

USS Russell Pyramid UFOs

Night vision footage from the USS Russell showed pyramid-shaped objects hovering over Navy destroyers during multi-ship encounters the Pentagon confirmed as genuine.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernment
2015•United States9/10

GoFast Video

A Navy F/A-18 ATFLIR pod captured a small, fast-moving object skimming over the ocean — one of three officially released Pentagon UFO videos.

DISPUTEDCE1military
2015•United States10/10

USS Roosevelt Gimbal/GoFast Encounters

Navy pilots from the USS Roosevelt captured the Pentagon-confirmed 'Gimbal' and 'GoFast' infrared videos of objects displaying anomalous flight characteristics.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernmentradar
2014•Chile9/10

Chilean Navy Helicopter UFO

A Chilean Navy helicopter captured 9 minutes of infrared video showing an unidentified object expelling unknown material, which Chile's official UAP agency could not explain after 2 years of analysis.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernmentradar
2013•Puerto Rico8/10

Aguadilla Transmedium Object

A US Customs aircraft captured IR video of an object entering the ocean and splitting in two near Puerto Rico, analyzed in a 160-page scientific report.

DISPUTEDCE1governmentradar
2008•United States7/10

Stephenville Sightings

Dozens of Texas residents observed a massive silent craft with military jets in pursuit, later confirmed by radar data showing the object near the presidential ranch.

DISPUTEDCE1militaryradarmass-sighting
2004•Mexico8/10

Mexican Air Force FLIR Encounter

A Mexican Air Force surveillance plane recorded 11 objects on FLIR and radar that were invisible to the naked eye - and Defense Minister Gen. Vega García released the footage on Mexican TV in May 2004, the first state-sanctioned military UAP video release in the Americas.

DISPUTEDmilitaryradargovernment
1997•United States8/10

Phoenix Lights

Thousands of witnesses including Arizona's governor observed a massive silent V-shaped craft and stationary orbs over Phoenix in one of the most witnessed UFO events ever.

DISPUTEDCE1mass-sightingmilitary
1996•Brazil7/10

Varginha Incident

Three women encountered a strange being in daylight in Varginha; military reportedly captured creatures, and a policeman who handled one died weeks later.

DISPUTEDCE3militarygovernment
1993•United Kingdom8/10

RAF Cosford / Shawbury Incident

Military personnel at two RAF bases observed a massive triangular craft with a searching beam of light; investigated by the MoD's Nick Pope.

DISPUTEDCE1military
1991•Mexico6/10

Mexico City Eclipse UFO

Thousands filming a solar eclipse over Mexico City independently captured footage of a metallic disc, creating one of the most widely filmed UFO events.

DISPUTEDCE1mass-sighting
1990•United Kingdom8/10

Calvine Incident

Two hikers photographed a diamond-shaped craft with a Harrier jet nearby in Scotland. The UK government classified the photos for over 30 years before one was released in 2022.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernment
1989•Belgium9/10

Belgian UFO Wave

Over 13,500 witnesses across Belgium reported massive silent triangular craft, confirmed by police, radar, and Belgian Air Force F-16 intercepts.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernmentradar
1989•United States5/10

Bob Lazar / Area 51 / S-4

Bob Lazar claimed to have reverse-engineered alien propulsion at 'S-4' near Area 51, describing Element 115 fuel years before its synthesis.

DISPUTEDgovernment
1987•United States5/10

Gulf Breeze Sightings

Builder Ed Walters captured extensive UFO photographs in Gulf Breeze, FL while hundreds of independent witnesses reported sightings during a months-long wave.

DISPUTEDCE1CE2mass-sighting
1986•United States8/10

Japan Airlines Flight 1628

A JAL 747 captain encountered a walnut-shaped object 'twice the size of an aircraft carrier' over Alaska, tracked on radar; FAA evidence was confiscated by CIA.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernmentradar
1982•United States7/10

Hudson Valley UFO Wave

Thousands reported a massive silent boomerang craft over the Hudson Valley for four years, documented in over 5,000 sighting reports.

DISPUTEDCE1mass-sighting
1980•United Kingdom9/10

Rendlesham Forest Incident

US Air Force personnel at a NATO base in England reported close encounters with a triangular craft over multiple nights, supported by physical evidence and an official memo.

DISPUTEDCE1CE2CE3military
1979•Spain9/10

Manises Incident

A Spanish airliner with 109 passengers made an emergency landing at Valencia after being shadowed by two bright objects; the Spanish Air Force scrambled a Mirage F1 that could not catch them - and the MoD's 1992 declassified file confirms the radar tracks.

DISPUTEDmilitaryradar
1978•New Zealand7/10

Kaikoura Lights

A TV film crew captured footage of luminous objects simultaneously tracked on Wellington radar off New Zealand's coast, investigated by the RNZAF.

DISPUTEDCE1militaryradarmass-sighting
1978•Canada7/10

Clarenville RCMP Encounter

RCMP Constable James Blackwood and twelve witnesses observed an oval craft with a fin hovering over water for two hours near Clarenville, which mimicked the flashing lights of his police cruiser.

DISPUTEDCE1
1976•Iran9/10

Tehran UFO Incident

Iranian Air Force F-4 Phantoms scrambled to intercept a UFO over Tehran experienced weapons and electronics failures, documented by a declassified DIA report.

DISPUTEDCE1CE2militarygovernment
1975•United States6/10

Travis Walton Abduction

Logger Travis Walton was struck by a beam from a hovering disc and vanished for 5 days; six coworkers who witnessed the event passed polygraph tests.

DISPUTEDCE4
1974•Mexico5/10

Coyame UFO Incident

An alleged midair collision between a small plane and a UFO near Coyame, Mexico, reportedly led to a covert U.S. military crash retrieval operation.

DISPUTEDmilitary
1974•United Kingdom6/10

Berwyn Mountain Incident

A seismic event, explosion, and glowing object on the Berwyn Mountains created the 'Welsh Roswell,' with allegations of military crash retrieval.

DISPUTEDCE1trace-evidence
1973•United States9/10

Coyne Helicopter Incident

A US Army helicopter was pulled upward 2,100 feet by an unknown force while a cigar-shaped object bathed it in a green beam, confirmed by ground witnesses.

DISPUTEDCE1CE2military
1973•United States8/10

Pascagoula Abduction

Two fishermen reported abduction by robotic beings; a secret sheriff's recording captured their genuine terror when they believed they were alone.

DISPUTEDCE3CE4
1973•International8/10

Skylab 3 Astronaut Sighting

Three NASA astronauts aboard Skylab 3 observed and photographed a bright red rotating object from orbit for over 10 minutes, with NORAD unable to identify any known object in the vicinity.

DISPUTEDCE1military
1972•Moon9/10

Apollo 17 - 'Fourth of July' Fragments

On December 11, 1972 the Apollo 17 crew described 'jagged angular fragments' tumbling past the spacecraft windows - 'the Fourth of July out of Ron's window.' The Pentagon re-classified the photographs from 'insulation' to 'potentially physical object' on May 8, 2026.

DISPUTEDmilitarygovernmenttrace-evidence
1971•United States8/10

Delphos Ring Case

A teenager witnessed a glowing object that left a hydrophobic ring in the soil with anomalous chemical properties persisting for years.

DISPUTEDCE2trace-evidence
1969•Moon7/10

Apollo 12 - Lunar-Sky Bright Objects

Apollo 12 photographs of bright unidentified objects above the lunar horizon were re-classified by the Department of War on May 8, 2026 from 'photographic artifact' to 'potentially the result of a physical object.'

DISPUTEDmilitarygovernmenttrace-evidence
1969•Moon5/10

Apollo 11 - Aldrin's Unidentified Object

Apollo 11 crew observed a luminous object pacing their spacecraft during translunar coast; the apocryphal 'they're warning us off' Armstrong transmission is the most-repeated UFO claim of the lunar era.

DISPUTEDmilitarygovernment
1969•United States6/10

Jimmy Carter UFO Sighting

Future U.S. President Jimmy Carter and ten witnesses observed a color-changing luminous object over Leary, Georgia, making it the only confirmed UFO sighting by an American president.

DISPUTEDCE1
1968•United States9/10

Minot AFB B-52 Encounter

A B-52 crew and ground personnel at Minot AFB simultaneously tracked a large luminous object on radar that disrupted UHF communications near nuclear missile sites.

DISPUTEDCE1CE2militarygovernment
1967•United States9/10

Malmstrom AFB Missile Shutdown

A glowing UFO hovered over Malmstrom AFB while 10 Minuteman nuclear missiles simultaneously went offline with no technical explanation found.

DISPUTEDCE1CE2militarygovernment
1966•United States8/10

Portage County UFO Chase

Four police officers across two states chased a luminous UFO for 86 miles; Blue Book's 'Venus' explanation was rejected by its own scientific consultant.

DISPUTEDCE1
1966•Australia8/10

Westall UFO Encounter

Over 200 students and teachers at a Melbourne school witnessed a silvery disc land in an adjacent field before authorities allegedly suppressed the story.

DISPUTEDCE1CE2mass-sightingtrace-evidence
1965•United States7/10

Kecksburg Incident

A controlled fireball landed near Kecksburg, PA; witnesses described an acorn-shaped craft with hieroglyphics before the Army removed it under secrecy.

DISPUTEDCE2militarygovernmenttrace-evidence
1964•United States7/10

Big Sur UFO / Vandenberg Missile Incident

An Air Force tracking-station film of a 1964 Atlas-F missile test reportedly captured a disc-shaped object firing four light-flashes that knocked the dummy warhead off-trajectory - one of the foundational nuclear-UAP-interaction cases.

DISPUTEDmilitary
1964•United Kingdom6/10

Solway Firth Spaceman

A photograph taken of a young girl on a marsh appeared to show a figure in a white spacesuit behind her. Kodak verified the negative was genuine and unaltered.

DISPUTEDCE1
1961•United States6/10

Betty and Barney Hill Abduction

The first widely publicized alien abduction case in the US, featuring missing time, hypnotic regression, and the iconic Betty Hill star map.

DISPUTEDCE4
1959•Papua New Guinea8/10

Father Gill Encounter

Anglican priest and 37 witnesses observed a hovering disc with humanoid figures who appeared to wave back when greeted, over a Papua New Guinea mission station.

DISPUTEDCE3mass-sighting
1959•Russia6/10

Dyatlov Pass Incident

Nine hikers died under bizarre circumstances in the Ural Mountains; the lead investigator believed the deaths were connected to reported luminous objects in the area.

DISPUTEDCE1
1958•Brazil8/10

Trindade Island Photos

A photographer aboard a Brazilian Navy ship captured photos of a Saturn-shaped UFO over Trindade Island, endorsed by the Navy and the President of Brazil.

DISPUTEDCE1military
1957•United States8/10

Levelland Electromagnetic Case

At least 15 independent witnesses near Levelland, TX reported a glowing object that killed vehicle engines and headlights at close range.

DISPUTEDCE2mass-sightingtrace-evidence
1957•United States9/10

RB-47 Reconnaissance Encounter

A USAF RB-47 reconnaissance bomber tracked an object on radar, electronic countermeasures, and visually for 700+ miles across multiple states.

DISPUTEDCE1militaryradar
1955•United States7/10

Kelly-Hopkinsville Encounter

The Sutton family reported hours-long siege by small luminous beings at their Kentucky farmhouse, prompting a multi-agency investigation.

DISPUTEDCE3
1954•Italy7/10

Florence Angel Hair Incident

An entire Serie A football match in Florence stopped when ~10,000 spectators watched cigar-shaped craft cross the sky and 'angel hair' fibers fell on the stadium - University of Florence chemists analyzed the residue.

DISPUTEDmass-sightingtrace-evidence
1952•International8/10

Operation Mainbrace UFO Sightings

During NATO's first major maritime exercise, US, UK, Danish, and other allied crews logged multiple radar+visual UFO sightings across the North Sea - one of the earliest multinational military UAP clusters.

DISPUTEDmilitarymass-sightingradar
1952•United States4/10

Flatwoods Monster Encounter

A group in Flatwoods, WV encountered a tall hissing entity near a glowing landed object, leaving witnesses physically ill during the 1952 UFO wave.

DISPUTEDCE3trace-evidence
1952•United States9/10

Washington DC UFO Incident

UFOs tracked on radar over the nation's capital on two consecutive weekends, triggering jet scrambles and the largest Pentagon press conference since WWII.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernmentradar
1952•United States7/10

Tremonton Utah Film

Navy photographer Delbert Newhouse filmed bright maneuvering objects over Utah; Navy analysis concluded they were 'intelligently controlled vehicles.'

DISPUTEDCE1military
1951•United States6/10

Lubbock Lights

V-formations of bluish-green lights observed by Texas Tech professors and photographed by a student became a classic unsolved Project Blue Book case.

DISPUTEDCE1mass-sighting
1950•United States7/10

Mariana UFO Film (Great Falls)

Nick Mariana filmed two bright rotating discs over Great Falls, Montana, producing one of the earliest credible pieces of UFO film evidence.

DISPUTEDCE1
1950•United States8/10

McMinnville (Trent) Photos

Paul and Evelyn Trent photographed a metallic disc over their Oregon farm, producing the most analyzed and authenticated UFO photos in history.

DISPUTEDCE1
1949•United States8/10

Los Alamos Green Fireball Conference

A 1949 Los Alamos conference transcript in which Manhattan Project physicists tried and failed to explain the 'green fireball' wave over the Southwest's nuclear laboratories. Released via PURSUE Release 04.

DISPUTEDgovernmentmass-sighting
1948•United States7/10

Gorman Dogfight

USAF pilot George Gorman engaged in a 27-minute aerial dogfight with a maneuvering light over Fargo that outperformed his P-51 Mustang.

DISPUTEDCE1military
1948•United States8/10

Chiles-Whitted Encounter

Two Eastern Airlines pilots observed a cigar-shaped craft with glowing windows pass their DC-3 at close range, prompting Project Sign's ET conclusion.

DISPUTEDCE1
1948•United States7/10

Sandia Base Green Orbs

Declassified file documenting 209 green-orb and disk sightings around the Sandia Base atomic-weapons complex, 1948-1950; released May 22, 2026 via PURSUE Release 02.

DISPUTEDmilitarygovernmentmass-sighting
1947•United States8/10

Roswell Incident

The US military initially announced recovery of a 'flying disc' near Roswell, NM before retracting the statement, creating the most famous UFO controversy in history.

DISPUTEDCE2militarygovernmenttrace-evidence
1947•United States7/10

Kenneth Arnold Sighting

Private pilot Kenneth Arnold's sighting of nine unusual objects near Mount Rainier launched the modern UFO era and coined the term 'flying saucers.'

DISPUTEDCE1military
1947•United States8/10

1947 Flying Disc Wave

Over 800 UFO sightings in just two weeks during the summer of 1947 created a nationwide phenomenon that launched government investigations and permanently changed American culture.

DISPUTEDmass-sightinggovernment
1946•Sweden7/10

Ghost Rockets of Scandinavia

Over 2,000 reports of rocket-shaped objects over Scandinavia prompted a Swedish military investigation that concluded 80% were unexplained.

DISPUTEDCE1militarygovernmentmass-sighting
1942•United States7/10

Battle of Los Angeles

The US military fired over 1,400 anti-aircraft rounds at unidentified objects over LA weeks after Pearl Harbor, with a famous searchlight photo capturing the event.

DISPUTEDCE1militarymass-sighting
1897•United States3/10

Aurora, Texas Airship Crash

During the 1897 airship wave, a craft allegedly crashed into a windmill in Aurora, TX, with reports of a non-human pilot buried in the local cemetery.

DISPUTEDtrace-evidence